Challenge Me on My Thoughts, Patterns and Behaviours in Therapy | Terra Soul Therapies

Why good therapy isn’t always about agreeing with you
I’ve always found it interesting how easily we can become convinced that the way we see something is the way it actually is.
We all have our own stories about ourselves, other people and the world around us. Some of these stories have been with us for so long that we don’t even question them anymore.
I’m not good enough.
People always let me down.
I have to keep everyone happy.
If I say what I really think, I’ll upset someone.
That’s just who I am.
But what if some of these beliefs aren’t quite as true as we think they are?
And what if the very things we’ve been doing to protect ourselves are now the things keeping us stuck?
I don’t want a therapist who always agrees with me
I think there’s something really valuable about having someone who is willing to gently challenge how we see ourselves and the situations we find ourselves in.
Someone who can ask, “Is that actually what happened, or is that how you’ve interpreted it?”
Or, “I’ve noticed this seems to happen quite often. I wonder what’s going on there?”
Not to prove us wrong, but to help us become curious about things we may never have questioned before.
As a psychotherapist, I don’t see my role as simply listening, nodding and agreeing with everything someone tells me.
Of course, being heard and understood matters enormously. Sometimes that’s exactly what someone needs.
But I also believe that therapy can offer something more.
A space where we can explore our assumptions, recognise our patterns and notice how we might unknowingly contribute to situations we desperately want to change.
And yes, sometimes that can be uncomfortable.
Sometimes our patterns make perfect sense
One of the things I’ve learnt through Gestalt and Sensorimotor Psychotherapy is that our behaviours often developed for very good reasons.
Perhaps you learnt to keep the peace because conflict felt unsafe growing up.
Maybe you became fiercely independent because relying on others led to disappointment.
Or perhaps you learnt to put everyone else’s needs before your own because being helpful was how you gained acceptance.
These ways of responding may have served you incredibly well at one point in your life.
The question isn’t whether they were right or wrong.
The question is whether they’re still working for you today.
Are you still avoiding conflict when you’d actually like to speak up?
Are you pushing people away when what you really want is connection?
Are you saying yes when everything in your body is telling you no?
These are the kinds of things I love exploring in therapy.
What if we challenged the story rather than the person?
There’s a big difference between challenging someone and making them feel criticised or judged.
For me, therapy isn’t about telling people what they’re doing wrong or how they should live their lives.
It’s about becoming curious together.
I might notice that someone’s words are saying one thing while their body seems to be expressing something quite different.
Or that they describe themselves as someone who isn’t angry, yet their fists tighten whenever they talk about a particular relationship.
Rather than jumping to conclusions, we can slow things down and explore what’s happening.
What are you noticing?
Does this feel familiar?
Where else does this happen in your life?
What might happen if you responded differently?
And sometimes, the most interesting question is simply, “What if that’s not true?”
Awareness gives us choices
I often think about how much of our lives we spend operating on autopilot.
We react, withdraw, defend ourselves, please others or become overwhelmed without always understanding why.
Then we find ourselves in the same situations, having the same arguments or experiencing the same frustrations.
And we wonder why nothing changes.
The wonderful thing about developing awareness is that we begin to recognise these patterns as they’re happening.
We might notice our shoulders tightening before we automatically agree to something we don’t want to do.
We might recognise that we’re assuming someone is angry with us simply because their tone has changed.
Or realise that we’re preparing to defend ourselves before the other person has even finished speaking.
That little moment of awareness can create an opportunity to do something different.
Not necessarily something dramatic.
Maybe we pause.
Maybe we ask a question rather than make an assumption.
Maybe we say no.
Maybe we allow ourselves to be vulnerable rather than putting up another wall.
Over time, those small moments can make a real difference.
And sometimes we need to laugh at ourselves
I don’t believe therapy needs to be serious all the time.
Some of the most meaningful moments can come when we recognise something we’ve been doing for years and suddenly see the absurdity of it.
There can be humour in noticing our own contradictions.
We might desperately want people to understand us while doing everything possible to hide how we’re actually feeling.
Or complain that nobody helps us, while refusing every offer of assistance.
We’re human. We’re complicated. And we don’t always make sense, even to ourselves.
I think there’s room to laugh about that, with kindness.
So, will I challenge you in therapy?
Yes, sometimes I will.
But not for the sake of challenging you.
And certainly not before we’ve built enough trust for that exploration to feel safe.
I’ll listen, I’ll be curious, and I’ll take your experiences seriously.
I might also invite you to look at something from a different perspective, notice what your body is communicating or experiment with responding in a new way.
And I welcome you challenging me, too. If something I say doesn’t fit, I want to know.
Therapy is a relationship, not a situation where I have all the answers.
My hope is that you leave therapy not simply feeling heard, but with a greater understanding of yourself and more freedom in how you choose to live.
Because sometimes the thing that needs to change isn’t the world around us, but how we meet it.
Curious about working together?
I’m Cath Sully, a psychotherapist, counsellor, Registered Nurse and Sensorimotor Psychotherapy practitioner at Terra Soul Therapies.
I work with adults experiencing anxiety, depression, trauma, burnout, relationship difficulties, grief and life changes, as well as people who have tried therapy before but still feel stuck.
My approach is curious, collaborative and body-based, drawing on Gestalt and Sensorimotor Psychotherapy.
If you’re looking for therapy that offers more than simply talking about what’s happening, I’d love to hear from you.
I offer sessions in person in Albion, Brisbane, and online across Australia.
Terra Soul Therapies
Helping you create a life that works for you.
Challenge Me on My Thoughts, Patterns and Behaviours





Comments